Nancy Jane Duncan - Female Rebel Spy

June of 1862 saw a marked change in policy how Union authorities in Kentucky dealt with Confederate sympathizers. On May 27, 1862, Secretary of War Edwin Stanton appointed Brigadier General Jeremiah T. Boyle as the new military commander of Kentucky. Boyle assumed his position on June 1, 1862. His predecessors had followed more conciliatory measures whereas Boyle believed “There are many so-called Union men in Kentucky who still cling to a hope of reconciliation and believe in a policy of leniency. I believe in subjugation--complete subjugation by hard and vigorous dealing with traitors and treason. Any other policy I beg to say in my opinion will be ruinous to us in Kentucky.” 

Brigadier General Jeremiah T. Boyle
Source: Wikipedia

After James A. Garfield's departure in early spring of 1862, Colonel Jonathan Cranor had taken command of the Union troops in Eastern Kentucky. After the Battle of Middle Creek, Garfield had implemented a policy of kindness. Before he left the Big Sandy Valley, Garfield instructed Cranor to see to the protection of citizens' rights and persons. He stressed that, "While all force and rebellion against the Government must promptly be put down, it must also be remembered that the people in this valley are to live together as fellow-citizens and neighbors after the war is over. All that we can do to inaugurate peace and concord among them while the army is here should be done." However, Cranor believed in sterner methods and found in Boyle a commander who was much more aligned with his own personal views. Thus began a series of arrests that would continue throughout the summer of 1862.

Although the majority of detainees were men, Boyle also began targeting suspected rebel women who showed their loyalty to the Confederate cause either as vocal supporters, spies, smugglers, guerrillas, or even as soldiers. While military authorities discounted women's activities at first as insignificant they soon began to realize the potential damage these women could cause. Up to this point, women had taken full advantage of the code of chivalry that called for women to be protected and cherished which generally shielded them from closer scrutiny and arrest.  Incarcerating women was considered barbarous and publicly condemned by many. However, a defiant Boyle declared, "The women think they will rule Kentucky but I will show them they can't do it while I am military governor." 

Cynthia Stewart was the wife of Johnson County attorney James E. Stewart who was a political prisoner at Camp Chase since his arrest shortly after the Battle of Middle Creek. She was living in Catlettsburg when Union authorities began monitoring her letters she was writing to her husband for any contraband news. It angered her that her private correspondence would be exposed so publicly and read by so many, to the point that she felt like giving up writing letters altogether. On July 2, 1862, Cynthia noted in one of her letters that, "there was a lady arrested here & sent to prison this week  I did not know her  sent to Louisville." 

The lady in question was Nancy Jane Duncan who first appeared in Eastern Kentucky on June 5, 1862, when she traveled up the Ohio River on board the Steamer Izetta and landed at Catlettsburg. According to the porter of the boat, "she had Seven heavy trunks on board, three of which were unloaded or put off here with her, and the other four were by her direction put off at Ceredo."

Gallipolis Journal, June 5, 1862

According to local informants, Mrs. Duncan passed through Catlettsburg, "pretending that she was trying to get to Carter county. Her movements excited suspicion at the time. She had several trunks very heavily laden with what is pretty well understood to be arms for the guerrillas in Morgan county." Provost Marshal Captain Matchett, 40th OVI, noted, "None of this baggage was inspected that I know of ~ It is very probably that the trunks contained Revolvers and Gun Caps and Cartridges."

It wasn't an unreasonable assumption, considering that other women had smuggled similar contraband across enemy lines. Women found creative ways to accomplish their objective, including concealing articles in coffins. It is unknown who the intended recipients of Nancy Jane Duncan's trunks were. As a note of interest, just a few miles above Ceredo, at Holderby's Landing, lived Sarah J. Stewart, wife of James Stewart, who had two sons in the Confederate army. At some point, Mrs. Stewart and her friend Mrs. Miller had gone through the lines into Kentucky, at Catlettsburg, in order to secure medicine to be sent by sympathizers into "Dixie." Both women were arrested as spies and held for some time, pending investigation. It was only through the efforts of a family friend, Dr. J. D. Kincaid, that the women were released. 

Nancy Jane Duncan did not linger at Catlettsburg. According to Provost Marshal Matchett she was closely watched after she left town with the remaining three trunks, "and her conduct was such as to satisfy people of her mission." The most likely mode of travel would have been one of the steamboats that plied up and down the Big Sandy River. The first stop on her journey was Cassville, in Wayne County, Virginia (now West Virginia), a small town situated right across the river from Louisa, Kentucky, a Union strong hold. At Cassville, she met and was welcomed by the families of James Stone, David Mitchell and Washington Ratliff. She boarded with James Stone whose wife Nancy maintained a hotel in town. Stone was a merchant and had come under suspicion of being a Southern sympathizer very early on in the War. Nancy Jane Duncan may have been a relative. (Stone was the s/o Ezekiel Stone & Edith Elizabeth Duncan) 

His close neighbors were David Mitchell, who operated a saddler shop, and Washington Ratliff who owned a small farm. While at Cassville, Nancy Jane Duncan seemed to have struck up friendships with James Stone's daughter Miss Edea Stone, as well as Miss Marey Mitchell, David Mitchells daughter and Miss Nancy Ann Ratliff, Washington Ratliff's daughter.  It is unclear how much time Nancy Jane Duncan spent in Cassville. Still carrying one or more of her heavy trunks, it is very likely that she enlisted the help of a trusted companion to convey them to Morgan County either by wagon or pack mule. Considering the circumstances, it was a dangerous mission to travel alone, especially as a woman. When she left town, she crossed the Big Sandy River by ferry and into Louisa. 

Nancy Jane Duncan did not remain in town any longer than necessary in order to avoid drawing too much attention to her person and was soon on her way to Morgan County. The most logical way for her to travel would have been on the road to Blaine, which is present-day KY Rt. 32. However, her presence did not escape the attention of Union authorities who may have been alerted about her in advance. She later noted, "they followed Me from Louisa to take My bagig but as they Dideant overtake Me the first Day they turned back." Her journey would have taken her past the house of Claibourne Swetnam, another well-known Confederate sympathizer, where she may have spent the night. Over the years Swetnam welcomed many travelers in his home, which would also include CSA General Humphrey Marshall just nine months later. 

Claibourne Swetnam House, Blaine, Kentucky
Source: Marlitta H. Perkins Collection

From Blaine, Nancy Jane Dunan's route continued on the main road to West Liberty, passing by Sagraves Mill to the junction with the Paintsville road. A few miles further another road forked off, leading through a mountain gap (near present-day Isonville) and up Newcombe Creek. A small bridle path leading from Kendall Branch connected Newcombe with the Middle Fork of Little Sandy River. It was somewhere in this area where Wood Lawn post office was located and where Nancy Jane Duncan's contact person William Green resided. Wood Lawn's post-master was Lewis Kendall whose brother Jesse, the former post-master, was now serving in the Confederate Army. 

Morgan County Postmasters, 1850s and 1860s

William Green was, in all likelihood, William Wellington Green, Sr. His wife was Sarah "Sallie" Hutchinson. William's grandmother was Jael Ellen Duncan before she married Samuel Stallard II. Again, it is possible that Nancy Jane Duncan was related to her host. She addressed him as "brother" but it may not have been meant literally but more figuratively, as in "brother in arms." 

If Nancy Jane Duncan was, indeed, carrying military supplies in her trunks as was suspected, it stands to reason that they may have been intended for Fields' Company of Partisan Rangers. At the time of her visit to the Middle Fork/Newcombe Creek area, the unit was in the early stages of formation in Morgan and Carter Counties. The commander was William Jason Fields (b. 1819, s/o James Anderson Fields & Elizabeth Maness) who was serving his fourth term as Carter County sheriff when the Civil War began. He subsequently joined the 5th KY Infantry (CS) and served as 2nd Lieutenant of Company G. After resigning his commission in 1862, he returned to Eastern Kentucky and began recruiting Fields' Rangers. His 1st cousin Preston Fields (son of William Jason Fields (1790) and Anna Creech (1801)) would serve in Fields' Rangers. He was married to William W. and Sallie Green's daughter Minerva since January 15, 1860.  

Other family members of William W. Green had ties to Fields' unit as well. William's sister Almeda was married to John Wesley Sparks, who, with his brother Hugh Sparks, served under Fields. Two of William Wellington Green's nephews, William M. and Francis Marion Green, sons of Robert Kilgore Green, were also members. 

While in Morgan County, Nancy Jane Duncan was able to briefly reunite with her daughters Lisey and Louisa who were living temporarily with William Green and his family. She found the girls, "all Well and harty and Doing Well." It was her hope to take them home with her on her next trip to Kentucky three months later. After visiting for a short while with her children and the Greens, Nancy Jane Duncan took her leave and returned to Catlettsburg, where she arrived on Saturday evening, June 28, 1862. It appears that she had a pre-arranged meeting with someone in town that may have been related to her business in Kentucky. She later mentioned that she was successful in meeting the appointment.

The following morning, after writing a letter to her friends in Cassville, Nancy Jane Duncan attended church services in Catlettsburg. Afterwards, she spent the afternoon writing a letter to William Green in Morgan County. She then took the letters to the post office and deposited them. Her plan was to leave Catlettsburg by boat that same evening in direction Cincinnati/Louisville. "A moment before she started she was surrounded at her hotel by several well known Sympathizers and was conversing rapidly ~" Matchett's spies were nearby, but "Only a few broken sentences however were overheard by my unsuspicicious eaves dropper - and, not enough to amount to prooff against her."

Matchett's trip to the post office, however, proved to be more successful. Her letters were retrieved and opened. Combined with several reports he had received about Nancy Jane Duncan's activities, Matchett felt confident that he had enough evidence to arrest her before she would be able to board a steam boat and leave town. 

Nancy Jane Duncan's letter to Morgan County, Kentucky

Nancy Jane Duncan's letter to Cassville, Virginia

The next morning, Monday, June 30, 1862, Nancy Jane Duncan was sent off to Louisville as a prisoner. In his letter to Louisville Provost Marshal Lt. Colonel Henry Dent, Matchett stated, "Being at a loss for proper instruction I send for your apprehension Mrs Nancy Jane Duncan to gather with two letters written by her and dropped in the Post Office of this place yesterday evening and by me extracted therefrom and opened. All thes(e) things however taken in connection with several reports not necessary to detail here and those letters taken from the P.O., which she acknowledges she wrote - and which I herewith forward to you justifies me I think in apprehending her, and pursuing the course I have taken."

Her arrest was mentioned in a number of papers, including the Louisville Daily Democrat, July 10, 1862 and the Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, July 12, 1862.

At this point, due to the lack of records, we lose track of Nancy Jane Duncan. The earliest prison record, Louisville Prison Register No. 1, begins in November of 1862. Names of citizens who were arrested were excluded from the register and kept separately and have not been located. 

Louisville Prison Register No. 1

At first, some female prisoners were put up in hotels, under guard. Others were taken to Barracks No. 2, a facility which normally served as a camp for paroled US soldiers. It was located on Main between Seventh and Eighth Streets. Due to the increase in numbers of female prisoners, General Boyle issued instructions on July 1, 1862, to the Provost Marshals throughout Kentucky "to fit up quarters for the imprisonment of such disloyal females" as they might find it necessary to arrest. 

Accordingly, Union authorities in Louisville took over a large house, situated between 12th and 13th Streets, at the corner of 13th and Broadway, and converted it into a military prison for women. It was within walking distance of the regular Military Prison, the Refugee Home, the Crittenden US General Hospital and a few blocks from the L & N. Railroad Depot.

The two-story building was described as a "good dwelling-house, well ventilated and dry." The grounds surrounding the house were spacious and shaded with fruit and ornamental trees. The women were allowed the full freedom of the grounds which were enclosed by a fence. The gate was guarded by a sentry on duty at that post. The women were supplied army rations, "yet prepared in such a manner as to render them palatable even to the delicate." The rooms were modestly furnished and contained on an average three double beds. The quarters were considered "airy, comfortable, and healthy." The sick were taken care of in two of the rooms in the back part of the building. In some cases, the incarcerated women were accompanied by their children. 

1865 map of Louisville. Red shaded area indicates the general
vicinity where the Female Military Prison was located. 
Map Source: LOC

Barracks near Crittenden US General Hospital, Broadway and 15th
Source: Historic Photos of Louisville Kentucky and Environs

In general, women prisoners were given several choices, depending on the severity of the charges:

- take the oath of allegiance and return home

- be jailed

- be exiled to Confederate lines, not to return for the duration of the war

- be released north of the Ohio River, not to return for the duration of the war

In absence of any type of records, it is difficult to determine which choice Nancy Jane Duncan made or what fate she and her children met. Her true identity has remained a mystery as she he may have operated under an assumed name. It is possible that further research may yet uncover a direct family connection between her and the Stone as well as the Green families. This is an on-going project and family researchers are encouraged to contact me with any additional information that may shed more light on Nancy Jane Duncan or the families she was involved with. 

Researched, transcribed and written by Marlitta H. Perkins, January/July 2023. Copyright © 2023. All Rights Reserved.

 

Links of Interest

Louisville and its Defences, 1865 map

Source: LOC

The Ruin of Cassville - History of a Virginia Bordertown During the Civil War

Source: Eastern Kentucky and the Civil War

The Loyalty of James Kendall Hunter

James Kendall Hunter

James Kendall Hunter was born in Morgan County, Kentucky, about 1832. He was the son of Benjamin Franklin “Francis” Hunter, also known as “Captain Frank”, and his wife Elizabeth Drake. Both Francis Hunter and his wife were Virginians by birth and came to Kentucky via Tennessee. The family lived in Pike County, Kentucky for a few years before settling in Morgan County by 1830. Over the next 16 years, Francis Hunter amassed a wealth of property in form of land grants. Most of the 1,600 acres he was awarded was situated between and along the Open Fork and Middle Fork of Little Sandy River.

We do not have much information regarding the early years of James K. Hunter, his childhood, upbringing or education but it appears that he inherited his father’s sense of business. In 1850, he was still living with his parents, working as a laborer. Ten years later, James K. Hunter was a substantial land owner in his own right, listing $3800 real estate and $1660 personal property in the 1860 Morgan County Census. On January 20, 1859, ready to support a wife and family of his own, he married Mary “Polly Ann” Clevenger, the 14 year old daughter of Pleasant Clevenger and wife Margaret Hamilton, in Morgan County, Kentucky. This marriage lasted only a few months. In absence of records we are only able to speculate what happened to Mary but it is entirely possible that she died, perhaps from complications of pregnancy or childbirth.

James K. Hunter did not mourn the loss of Polly Ann for very long and soon was courting Edy Howard, the 17 year old daughter of Dyer Howard and Celia “Sealie” Adkins. There is no record for this marriage, but by June of 1860, James K. Hunter was living with his new wife Edy and four month old daughter Almarinda, in District One of Morgan County, near Gordon Ford in Horseshoe Bend of Licking River.

The following year, the dark clouds of war soon overshadowed Hunter’s happy home life. In early fall of 1861, James K. Hunter began raising a company of volunteers for the Confederate Army. James H. Morgan, a Morgan County resident who later had to flee from the rebels and live as a refugee in Greenup County, stated that, “about Oct 1, 1861 James Hunter, in Company with some others took affiants gun from him. Hunter was then in the Rebel service, & from the information I had was a Captain in the Rebel Army.” A good portion of Hunter’s men came from the Middle Fork District in Morgan County, KY. He was joined in his recruiting efforts by his brother-in-law Peter M. Fannin, husband of his sister Nancy.

On October 21, 1861, the company was enlisted in the Confederate service at West Liberty by Andrew Jackson May. Two days later, federal troops under General William "Bull" Nelson captured West Liberty and the Confederates were forced to beat a hasty retreat to Prestonsburg. It was here, on October 25, 1861, that James K. Hunter and his men were sworn into the service by Lt. R. B. Howard. His company became Co. B of the 5th KY Mounted Infantry, commanded by Colonel John S. Williams. Hunter was elected Captain, Henry T. Stanton, a young lawyer from Maysville , 1st Lieutenant, and both Joseph Adkins and Peter M. Fannin, 2nd Lieutenants.

The following month, after the Battle of Ivy Mountain on November 8, 1861, the Confederates retreated into Southwestern Virginia, while the 5th KY Infantry encamped at Pound Gap. After nearly a month, Confederate forces, including the 5th KY Infantry, under command of Brig. Gen. Humphrey Marshall, re-entered Eastern Kentucky and slowly proceeded down the Big Sandy Valley. By December 1861, a camp was set up at Hager Hill, in Johnson County, near Paintsville where more recruits were received and supplies were gathered. Captain James K. Hunter arranged to have 122 hogs driven to camp which he sold to the CS Government for a whopping $1,151.76 on January 4, 1862.

Receipt for $1,151.76 for 122 hogs

Less than a week later, on January 10, 1862, Marshall’s troops faced the Union forces under Colonel James A. Garfield at Middle Creek in Floyd County, Kentucky. The battle ended with a Confederate defeat. Marshall left the field and retreated with his men to Martin’s Mill in Floyd Co. KY. It was here, in camp on Beaver Creek, where Captain Hunter was paid for his hogs, on January 15, 1862. Twelve days later, on January 27, 1862, the 5th KY Infantry, including Hunter’s company, was encamped on the banks of the Kentucky River, near Whitesburg, Kentucky. Hunter requisitioned camp and garrison equipage such as tents and clothing for his men and was generally attending to his duties.

What happened next was unexpected and is truly inexplicable. Within a matter of days, Captain Hunter deserted his men and his regiment and returned home to Morgan County. Why he did not simply choose to resign instead of deserting his men is hard to explain. Was he pressed by some urgent matter, was he physically unable to withstand the rigors of campaigning and military life, or did he become disillusioned with the Southern cause? Or were his actions due to pressure by his family who were, for the most part, Union supporters? After all, during the course of the Civil War, no less than three of James K. Hunter’s brothers, four nephews and one brother-in-law enlisted in the Union Army.* His father Francis was also known to be a loyal man. Unfortunately, the records are silent and void of any reasonable explanation.

Company Muster Roll, Co. B
5th KY Infantry (CS)
Dec. 31, 1861 - Apr. 30, 1862

Regardless of Hunter’s motives, he returned home to his wife and young daughter but his stay, for the time being, was cut short. About February 7, 1862, a federal cavalry patrol, Wolford’s 1st KY Cavalry, captured James K. Hunter at his Morgan County home and brought him to Camp Buell, Garfield’s Headquarters, at Paintsville, Johnson County, KY. Surprisingly, Hunter was not sent off to Newport Barracks or Camp Chase as a prisoner of war. Undoubtedly, Garfield interviewed Hunter and must have been sufficiently convinced that Hunter was not in communication with the rebel army anymore or aiding the enemy. Yet, Garfield still did not trust him enough to release him simply on his word of honor. James K. Hunter was allowed to post bond and, upon taking the oath of allegiance, he was permitted to return home.

Head Quarters 18th Brigade
Camp Buell Feb 13 1862

James K. Hunter of Morgan county Ky having come into camp and taken an oath of allegiance to the Government of the United States and entered into bonds to remain a true and faithful citizen. (He) thereof is hereafter considered as under the protection of the Federal Army and will in no way be molested so long as he shall remain at home a peaceable citizen.

By order of
Col. J. A. Garfield
Comdg Brigade

W. H. Clapp
A. A. G.

Garfield's order dated Feb. 13, 1862

During the following months, Hunter seemed to abide by the terms and conditions of the oath and bond and remained at his home in Morgan County, attending to his own personal affairs. John T. Shepherd, postmaster at Grayson, Carter Co. KY noted that, ”when I saw him he was attending to his business as any other citizen After he gave bond as aforesaid For the Purpose of ascertaining whether he was Keeping the Condition of his Bond - at Every Chance I had - I made Enquiry of his neighbors where he was and what he was doing and always understood that he was at home and behaving himself.” James M. Gray of Morgan County noted that Hunter, “since he gave a bond to Col J A Garfield in the winter of 1862 that he has since that time he has been at home or not connected with either army Federal or confederate.”

Another child was welcomed into the family who was named Jefferson Davis Hunter. The first name is an interesting choice but in absence of an exact birth date it remains unclear if the child was named before or after his father’s desertion from the Confederate Army.

At the beginning of August 1862, the State of Kentucky was threatened by a massive Confederate invasion under Generals Bragg, Kirby Smith and Humphrey Marshall.

On September 17, 1862, Marshall’s men, including Hunter’s former regiment, the 5th KY Infantry, arrived in Morgan County, and, “marched thru West Liberty with a brass band and drum and fife in great pomp.” The soldiers received a warm welcome. James K. Hunter, however, may have looked upon this spectacle with mixed feelings. Captain Joseph Adkins, who was now commanding Hunter’s Company B, promptly stopped at Hunter’s home and arrested him, and, according to Davidson Davis, “forced him of as a prisoner much against his will.” James M. Gray, Hunter’s neighbor, stated, “that he was present at J. K. Hunters and seen him taken off under an arrest by some of Capt Adkins Company of Gen Marshals.” F. C. Walsh later saw, “a portion of the soldiers of the Confederate Army as they passed through West Liberty. James Hunter, was with a lot of soldiers I saw He was acting with them but in what Capacity, I did not hear any one say; don't know that he was captain.” Jackson B. Ward and Benjamin F. Crawford stated that Hunter was taken “away by the Rebels a prisoner”.” Jesse K. Howard noted that, “Men under Colonel May of the Rebel army arrested James K Hunter and took him off to the Rebel Army and he was then dismissed and allowed to Come back home.” Eyewitnesses such as Davidson Davis and James M. Gray added that Hunter was gone “some ten or twelve days.”

After his return to Morgan County, James K. Hunter went into the horse trading business with Jesse K. Howard. At the end of 1862, Hunter and Howard proceeded to Greenup County and lodged at Seymore Harding’s hotel in Greenupsburg, waiting to board a steamship to Cincinnati. According to Harding, “They had some horses they told me they were taking them to Cincinnati to sell them.” A similar trip was undertaken about mid-February 1863.

During a third trip at the end of March of 1863, Hunter was recognized in Greenupsburg by some Morgan County refugees, among them James H. Morgan, who notified Provost Marshall William C. Ireland of his presence. “I am informed by refugees from Morgan Co. that James Hunter was a Captain in the Rebel Army, and was commanding a Co., at the battle of Middle Creek on Big Sandy, “noted Ireland. It was also stated that Hunter had, “raised a Company, and went into the rebel service“, during the Confederate invasion of Kentucky in the summer of 1862. “Went off and was gone until a month or so ago.”

Ireland decided against an immediate arrest of Hunter and Howard and instead, addressed a letter to Enoch T. Carson, Collector of the Port of Cincinnati and the United States, on March 21, 1863. “Not being advised as to who is in military command at your city, I write you, knowing that you will place this in proper hands. There is now at this place two men waiting for a boat to go to your city. James Hunter, and Jesse K. Howard. They have 4 horses, and a gray (?), that they say they are taking down to Sell … I would have arrested them here, but have no forces at my command, and no safe place to keep them. I would arrest notwithstanding, but for the fact that they are going to your city where they can be properly cared for. If they are arrested, and if proof of the facts stated is required, I will forward testimony.” He added a physical description of Hunter and Howard. “Hunter, is about 28, or 30 years of age, dark hair, dark whiskers, about 6 feet high. He resides I understand in Morgan Co. Ky. Is a son of Frank Hunter who is said to be a Union man … Howard, who is with Hunter, is a large man - weighing say 180 lbs. dark hair, age about 30 years … Both wear soft black hats. Howard, has some hair on chin of rather (?) sandy color.”

Apparently unaware of the trouble that was brewing, Hunter and Howard boarded the next steamship at Greenupsburg with their horses and proceeded to Cincinnati. Upon their arrival on March 25, 1863, both men were promptly arrested and their horses seized, upon orders of Colonel Eastman. Hunter and Howard were then taken to the barracks on Columbia Street in Cincinnati.

Meanwhile, Provost Marshal William C. Ireland made every effort to locate witnesses for this case but believed that, “it would not be safe to go to Morgan Co.” Despite the apparent hurdles, Ireland managed within three weeks to obtain the affidavits and statements of 15 witnesses. On March 31, 1863, James K. Hunter’s father Frank stopped at Ireland’s office with two affidavits in his pocket in favor of his son while on his way to Cincinnati. Ireland did not seem to be completely satisfied, however, and continued to search for witnesses. The last affidavit in Hunter’s case was taken on April 8, 1863.

It appears that Jesse K. Howard was soon released and was allowed to return to Morgan County. Provost Marshal Ireland noted that, “They say Howard, who is with Hunter, has never been in the Rebel Army but is a sort of tool for Hunter.” James H. Morgan noted that, “I have known Jesse K. Howard for several years and so far as his Loyalty is concerned within my own knowledge I cannot say but this much I can say - I have never heard of his Taking any part whatever in this Rebellion so far as truth or veracity is concerned I have never heard him doubted.” James Walsh, a private in Co. D, 14th KY Cavalry (US), knew Howard well and characterized him as a “notorious rebel & sympathizer” but as far as he knew or believed he had never been in arms.

In regard to James K. Hunter, Greenup postmaster Joseph Pollock stated, “that a short time after the Federal forces under Genl George Morgan passed through this place, he had a talk with several men, some of whom were members of the 22nd Ky Infantry, & others Tennesseans … These men informed me that they learned as they passed through Morgan Co. Ky, that a man by the name of Hunter, was trying to get recruits for the Rebel Army. I do not remember that they gave his given name, but I learned from them (?) that he was a son of Frank Hunter of Morgan County, and that he had been before that time in the Rebel Army.”

US Brig. General George W. Morgan had entered West Liberty with his 7th Division, Army of the Ohio, on September 28, 1862, only 11 days after Hunter had been taken off as a prisoner by Captain Adkins of the 5th KY. As witnesses had stated, Hunter did not return home until some ten or twelve days later. Since Hunter was most likely still absent from Morgan County during the time Federal Morgan’s troops passed through the county, it would only be natural for people to speculate or assume that he had re-joined the Confederate Army and make statements to that effect to the Union troops. But return he did shortly thereafter and “since that time he has been attending to the ordinary avocations of life and not in the army,” as was noted his neighbor James M. Gray.

Interestingly, the initial statement by an unnamed witness to Provost Marshal Ireland that Hunter “Went off and was gone until a month or so ago”, which would fix his date of return to Morgan County to mid to late February of 1863, does not appear in any of the witnesses’ affidavits. Furthermore, it was easily discredited by Seymore Harding’s testimony who had seen Hunter and Howard in Greenup at his hotel at the end of December 1862 and again in mid- February 1863, on their way to Cincinnati to sell horses.

Seymore Harding affidavit, March 29, 1863

Harding’s testimony also raises doubt about James H. Morgan’s statement that, “Sometime in December I was in Morgan County, and heard it said that Hunter has been trying to raise a company for the Rebel service,” but Morgan himself admitted that, “of the truth of the matter, personally I know nothing.” It is possible that Morgan had personal reasons to implicate Hunter, and was trying to get even for the visit that Hunter had paid him in October 1861, when his gun was taken from him.

The overwhelming majority of the witnesses testified in Hunter’s favor, stating that, once he returned to Morgan County, after being captured by Captain Adkins and taken off as a prisoner, Hunter had remained home and attended to his own business. Davidson Davis noted that Hunter,“has since been at home or attending to his ordinary business of life and that he has frequently heard said Hunter say that he never intended to violate his bond that he had given. “Jackson B. Ward also added that “from all I have been able to See or hear of him he has been guilty of no disloyal acts or Conduct.”

Additionally, on March 31, 1863, Robert F. Prater, a soldier of Company B, 14th KY Cavalry (US) was questioned and cross-examined in Cincinnati, in reference to the loyalty of James K. Hunter to the Government of the United States.

An excerpt is given here:

Robert F. Prater first duly sworn deposeth and sayeth:

Question 1st. ~ What is your age. Where do you reside and what is your occupation.

Answer. Twenty Three years of age. I reside in Morgan County, Ky. Soldier in the United States Army.

Question 2d. ~Are you acquainted with James K. Hunter and how long have you been acquainted with him

Answer - I am acquainted with James K. Hunter and have known him for five years.

Question 3d. ~What is said James K. Hunter's reputation.

Answer - His reputation as far as I know is good.

Question 4. ~What do you know of his loyalty since February 7th 1862.

Answer. As far as I know he has been loyal ever since.

Question 5. ~Do you know of his having raised a company for the Rebel army since February 7th 1862.

Answer - He has not raised a company that I know of

Question 6. What portion of the time since February 7th 1862 have you resided in the same vicinity with defendent

Answer - About Six months

7 Question . ~Have you been in his vicinity since the 1st of september 1862

Answer - I have

8 Question ~ Do you know of defendent having raised a company for the Rebel army during the month of August 1862 or at any time since

Answer - He has not that I know of my reason for so stating is that I have frequently been through the neighborhood where he resides as a scout as a soldier during the fall and winter of 1862 and he was at home

The records do not disclose whether the charges of disloyalty against Hunter were dropped or not but in view of the testimony in favor of his case it seems unlikely that he was held by the authorities for very long. It may be noted that James K. Hunter’s name does not appear on any Confederate military records after his desertion in 1862 which lends added credibility to the statements made by witnesses who testified on his behalf.

Hunter returned home and during the remaining war years, two more children were added to the family - daughter Arvilla, born abt. 1864 and son William D., born ca. 1865. George Montgomery, born in March of 1866 and Laura B., born abt. 1868, soon followed.

After the end of the Civil war, James K. Hunter rose to prominence in local affairs. In 1869, we find James K. Hunter as a resident of the newly formed Elliott County, KY. On April 5, 1869, the county seat was laid off on a one acre plot in Martinsburg that had been generously donated by Hunter. On the same day, a committee composed of James K. Hunter, G. W. Stamper, W. H. Vansant, Travis Horton and A. Ison met at Hunter’s home for the purpose of dividing the county into five districts, or voting precincts.

On May 25, 1869, the first session of court conducted in the new county was convened Hunter’s steam mill on the bank of Little Sandy River. James K. Hunter served as the first Elliott County Judge and his mill was fixed as the permanent meeting place for both county and circuit court until a more suitable place could be found and provided.

The 1870 Elliott County Census reveals that Hunter had made it through the Civil War financially unscathed. He was a merchant in Martinsburg and owned $8000 worth of real estate and $12,200 personal property. During the same year, on July 3, his daughter Mollie Belle Barbour Hunter was born. Hunter seemed at the height of his personal and professional life and was considered an influential citizen. Two short years later, tragedy struck when James K. Hunter was killed by a fall from his horse. The exact circumstances of his death remain unknown. The 1873 Elliott County Tax List shows Judge James K. Hunter as deceased. His final resting place is in the Old Sandy Hook Cemetery. His 29 year old widow Edy Hunter, who was left to raise 7 small children, joined her husband’s side 44 years later, on August 23, 1916, one day after her death at Sandy Hook of cerebral hemorrhage.

Eda "Edy" Hunter Death Certificate

*James K. Hunter’s Family Members in the Federal service
Nephew - James M. Vansant, Co. B, 14th KY Cav (US) – son of J.K. Hunter’s sister Lavisa Susan
Nephew - Sylvester Green Hunter, Pvt., Co. B, 14 KY Cav (US) – son of J. K. Hunter’s sister Emerine

Brother - Squire Henderson Hunter, Pvt., Co. C, 40th KY Inf. (US)
Nephew - James M. Hunter also Pvt., Co. C, 40th KY Inf. (US) – son of Squire Henderson Hunter

Brother-in-law - Lewis A. Thornbury, Sgt. Maj. in Co. D, 39th KY Inf. (US)– husband of J. K. Hunter’s sister America. Lewis A. Thornbury was a brother of Captain Martin Thornsbury, Co. D, 39th KY Inf. (US)
Brother - Kenas F. Hunter, Pvt. Co. D, 39th KY Inf. (US)
Brother – William Thomas Hunter, Pvt. Co. D, 39th KY Inf. (US)
Nephew – Martin Hunter, Pvt. Co. D, 39th KY Inf. (US) – son of J. K. Hunter’s brother Sylvester D.


Source Records
Compiled Service Records, Confederate and Union
Confederate Citizens files
Union Provost Marshal Records


Article researched and written by Marlitta H. Perkins, December 2012. Unauthorized use and/or duplication without express written notice by the author is strictly prohibited. © 2012. All Rights Reserved.